Miscellaneous Vintage Fishing Lures.

We have a taste of several different companies like The Mercoy Tackle Company of Grosse Point, Michigan, who first introduced the Mercury Minnow fishing lure in 1949. The Mercury minnow is just that, it’s call to fame coming from the ball of Mercury that rolls around inside the lure, creating a wobble action when it’s retrieved, coming with the slogan “It act’s alive”. C.C. Roberts rare Mud Puppy lures.  Early Gibbs tool and Stamping works, with our early Gibbs Martin Salmon Plug. We will set up some of our unboxed lures here also as we get them photographed.

Littlemudpuppy
Littlemudpuppy

C.C Roberts Little Mud Puppy in Sucker Finish. Early WWII model.

press to zoom
LittleMudPuppy
LittleMudPuppy

C.C Roberts Little Mud Puppy in Sucker Finish. Early WWII model.

press to zoom
LittleMudPuppy
LittleMudPuppy

C.C Roberts Little Mud Puppy in Sucker Finish. Early WWII model.

press to zoom
Littlemudpuppy
Littlemudpuppy

C.C Roberts Little Mud Puppy in Sucker Finish. Early WWII model.

press to zoom
1/6

Early 1940’s C.C Roberts Little Mud Puppy in Sucker Finish. This lure is a more rare, uncommon one as it has painted eyes and the factory WWII wire wrapped hooks and an early correct picture box which is one of the more uncommon boxes.

MercuryMinnow
MercuryMinnow

Mercury Minnow in Perch Color.

press to zoom
MercuryMinnow
MercuryMinnow

Mercury Minnow in Perch Color.

press to zoom
MercuryMinnow
MercuryMinnow

Mercury Minnow in Perch Color.

press to zoom
MercuryMinnow
MercuryMinnow

Mercury Minnow in Perch Color.

press to zoom
1/9

This Early Mercury Minnow is the Perch color lure complete with the hard to come by early silver box and paperwork. We are on the look out for an orange Mercury Minnow also. If you have an orange version you would like to trade please contact us.

Naturalure
Naturalure

Naturalure Strikee minnow.

press to zoom
Naturalure
Naturalure

Naturalure Strikee minnow.

press to zoom
Naturalure
Naturalure

Naturalure Strikee minnow.

press to zoom
Naturalure
Naturalure

Naturalure Strikee minnow.

press to zoom
1/4

This Naturalure is a special one because it was given to us by Gary Love Sr. My dad, he was given this lure in California by his Dad who purchased this lure at a local tackle shop. Naturalure Bait Co. from Pasadena California, great Life like Lures. The fins become soft and life like when in water.

Kicknkackle
Kicknkackle

Frog Color Kick N Kackle

press to zoom
Kickinkackle
Kickinkackle

Frog Color Kick N Kackle

press to zoom
Kicknkackle
Kicknkackle

Frog Color Kick N Kackle

press to zoom
Kicknkackle
Kicknkackle

Frog Color Kick N Kackle

press to zoom
1/6

The Kick-N-Kackle in Frog color, these were made by Orchard Industries in the great state of Michigan.

L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S Mira Lure 00M

press to zoom
L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S Mira Lure 00M

press to zoom
L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S Mira Lure 00M

press to zoom
L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S Mira Lure 00M

press to zoom
1/6

L&S Mira-Lure dates to the 1950's this model No. 00M23 has a great color range #23 and is a deadly bait for Walleye and Bass. This bait was crafted in the Clearwater Florida factory.

L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S PanfishSinker

press to zoom
L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S PanfishSinker

press to zoom
L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S PanfishSinker

press to zoom
L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S PanfishSinker

press to zoom
1/3

L&S Panfish Sinker dates to the early 1950's this model Panfish Sinker has a great color range No. 11 Silver Scale. This bait was crafted in the Illinois factory. 

LuckyStrikeScamp
LuckyStrikeScamp

Limited Edition Lucky Strike Little Scamp Minnow

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeScamp
LuckyStrikeScamp

Limited Edition Lucky Strike Little Scamp Minnow

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeScamp
LuckyStrikeScamp

Limited Edition Lucky Strike Little Scamp Minnow

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeScamp
LuckyStrikeScamp

Limited Edition Lucky Strike Little Scamp Minnow

press to zoom
1/7

Founder Frank Edgar's Son William, went to the effort to get the original tools working to hand craft these limited edition lures.

LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2004

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2004

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2004

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2004

press to zoom
1/6

This amazing condition Lucky Strike Muskie Plug is a #2004. We sold this lure to a collector in Canada in 2022.

LuckStrike3502
LuckStrike3502

Lucky Strike Submarine #3502 Red Head

press to zoom
LuckyStrike3502
LuckyStrike3502

Lucky Strike Submarine #3502 Red Head

press to zoom
LuckyStrike3502
LuckyStrike3502

Lucky Strike Submarine #3502 Red Head

press to zoom
LuckStrike3502
LuckStrike3502

Lucky Strike Submarine #3502 Red Head

press to zoom
1/5

This Lucky Strike Submarine is a #3502 Red & White, It  has gold eyes. This one was given to us by Joe Makarowski. Joe bought this lure new in the 1946 sometime after WWII. One of his favorite lures Joe filled it with Mercury to make it dive deep. Joe gave it to Gary in 1999 to preserve it and save it. This lure was in on a lot of fishing, and has a great story beyond what we've posted here.  

LuckyStrikeRWPlug
LuckyStrikeRWPlug

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Red and White, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeRWPlug
LuckyStrikeRWPlug

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Red and White, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeRWPlug
LuckyStrikeRWPlug

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Red and White, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeRWPlug
LuckyStrikeRWPlug

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Red and White, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
1/5

This great condition Lucky Strike Plug  is a 3.5 inch plug in Red and White, These no eye's plugs are somewhat uncommon. We sold this lure to a Canadian collector in 2022.

MudPuppy
MudPuppy

Standard Size Mud Puppy by C.C Roberts. WWII Era Unfished EX+ Shiny Condition.

press to zoom
MudPuppy
MudPuppy

Standard Size Mud Puppy by C.C Roberts. WWII Era Unfished EX+ Shiny Condition.

press to zoom
MudPuppy
MudPuppy

Standard Size Mud Puppy by C.C Roberts. WWII Era Unfished EX+ Shiny Condition.

press to zoom
MudPuppy
MudPuppy

Standard Size Mud Puppy by C.C Roberts. WWII Era Unfished EX+ Shiny Condition.

press to zoom
1/5

Early 1940’s C.C Roberts Standard Size Mud Puppy in Sucker Finish grading EX+ Unfished well preserved WWII Lure. This lure is a more rare, uncommon one as it has painted eyes and the factory WWII wire wrapped soldered hooks. A Fantastic piece of History.

GibbsMartin
GibbsMartin

41/2 Silver Scale Salmon Plug.

press to zoom
GibbsMartin
GibbsMartin

41/2 Silver Scale Salmon Plug.

press to zoom
GibbsMartin
GibbsMartin

41/2 Silver Scale Salmon Plug.

press to zoom
GibbsMartin
GibbsMartin

41/2 Silver Scale Salmon Plug.

press to zoom
1/7

This is a great lure, this one comes from the Gibbs Tool & Stamping works in Vancouver B.C. With a rare early double label box & with a Silver Scale Salmon Plug in 41/2 inches. This is an early Gibbs Martin Salmon Plug in correct box. This Combo is up for Trade!

SpinnoMinno
SpinnoMinno

Spinno-Minno in frog color.

press to zoom
SpinnoMinno
SpinnoMinno

Spinno-Minno in frog color.

press to zoom
SpinnoMinno
SpinnoMinno

Spinno-Minno in frog color.

press to zoom
SpinnoMinno
SpinnoMinno

Spinno-Minno in frog color.

press to zoom
1/5

The Spinno Minno series 500 in Frog color. Produced by Pecos River Tackle Company of Carlsbad, New Mexico, founded in 1944. These cool bass lures feature an aluminum disk inside to provide action to the lure. These are a favorite among collectors.

DAMbrownmouse
DAMbrownmouse

Vintage DAM Brown Mouse.

press to zoom
DAMbrownmouse
DAMbrownmouse

Vintage DAM Brown Mouse.

press to zoom
DAMbrownmouse
DAMbrownmouse

Vintage DAM Brown Mouse.

press to zoom
DAMbrownmouse
DAMbrownmouse

Vintage DAM Brown Mouse.

press to zoom
1/7

DAM German Made Brown Mouse, these versions of mice are very very good, DAM did a fantastic job on their mouse imitation. Flocked fur and leather ears these lures are high quality vintage collector masterpieces.

L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S PikeMaster

press to zoom
L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S PikeMaster

press to zoom
L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S PikeMaster

press to zoom
L&SFishingLure
L&SFishingLure

L&S PikeMaster

press to zoom
1/4

L&S PikeMaster dates to the early 1950's this model PikeMaster has a great color range Silver Flitter. This bait was crafted in the Illinois factory. 

ShurkatchNo.80RH
ShurkatchNo.80RH

Vintage Shurkatch No. 80 Jointed Minnow in Read Head or RH color code.

press to zoom
ShurkatchNo.80RH
ShurkatchNo.80RH

Vintage Shurkatch No. 80 Jointed Minnow in Read Head or RH color code.

press to zoom
ShurkatchNo.80RH
ShurkatchNo.80RH

Vintage Shurkatch No. 80 Jointed Minnow in Read Head or RH color code.

press to zoom
ShurkatchNo.80RH
ShurkatchNo.80RH

Vintage Shurkatch No. 80 Jointed Minnow in Read Head or RH color code.

press to zoom
1/4

Shurkatch Baits No. 80 Jointed Minnow in RH color code Red Head. This lure is 4 1/4 inches long has the one piece Shurkatch lip and hook hanger. Shurkatch Baits was located in Richfield Springs New York and produced lures from the 1920's into the 1950's. Many Shurkatch lures are often confused with other brands like Paw Paw, Arnold, South Bend, Meadowbrook and Shur-Strike. Getting the correct length and checking the hardware are key to getting the ID on a Shurkatch. Many were sold on dealer cards which were located on the counter top of tackle shops, with multiple various lures on the card to be picked from.

LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2002

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2002

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2002

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2002

press to zoom
1/4

This amazing condition Lucky Strike Muskie Plug  is a #2002. Sold to a collector in the U.S in 2022.

LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2021

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2021

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2021

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug
LuckyStrikeMuskiePlug

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug #2021

press to zoom
1/5

This amazing condition Lucky Strike Muskie Plug is a #2021 Yellow Perch. It  has tack eyes and was never used. This one was given to me by my Dad Gary Love Sr. Dad said he never used this lure. Because he was too busy field testing my Jackfish Lures Spinners.

LuckyStrikeGP
LuckyStrikeGP

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug 6 inch in Green Pike

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeGP
LuckyStrikeGP

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug 6 inch in Green Pike

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeGP
LuckyStrikeGP

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug 6 inch in Green Pike

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeGP
LuckyStrikeGP

Lucky Strike Muskie Plug 6 inch in Green Pike

press to zoom
1/4

This amazing condition Lucky Strike Muskie Plug is a 6" Straight model in Green Pike color, in EX++ Condition. It dates to the 1960's has tack eyes and was never used,  we sold this lure to a collector in Canada in 2022.

LuckyStrikeSBPlug
LuckyStrikeSBPlug

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Black with silver scale, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeSBPlug
LuckyStrikeSBPlug

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Black with silver scale, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeSBPlug
LuckyStrikeSBPlug

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Black with silver scale, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeSBPlug
LuckyStrikeSBPlug

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Black with silver scale, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
1/6

This Lucky Strike Plug  is a 3.5 inch plug in Black Top with Silver Scale. These no eye's plugs are somewhat uncommon. We sold this lure to a Canadian Collector in 2022.

LuckyStrikeNoEye
LuckyStrikeNoEye

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Green/Olive Gold scale, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeNoEye
LuckyStrikeNoEye

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Green/Olive Gold scale, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeNoEye
LuckyStrikeNoEye

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Green/Olive Gold scale, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
LuckyStrikeNoEye
LuckyStrikeNoEye

Lucky Strike 3.5 inch plug in Green/Olive Gold scale, an uncommon no eye's plug.

press to zoom
1/6

Lucky Strike Plug  at 3.5 inches, in Green/Olive Top with Gold Scale. These no eye's plugs are somewhat uncommon, we sold this lure to a Canadian Collector in 2022.

More great Lures coming soon as we build our site. Check back often to see more.